Lost Sales vs. Stockouts: Why Lacking the Tools to Differentiate Them Could Cost You Millions

Your latest footwear or apparel line is flying off the shelves. Excitement builds as you watch sales numbers soar. But then, disaster strikes. Your bestselling sizes are suddenly out of stock, and customers are leaving empty-handed. In a panic, you rush to reorder, doubling your usual quantity. Weeks later, you're drowning in excess inventory, marking down prices, and watching profit margins evaporate.

Sound familiar? This nightmare scenario is all too common in the apparel and footwear industry, and it often stems from an inability to differentiate lost sales from stockouts.

Modern merchandisers are sophisticated, so it's unlikely you’re conflating these two concepts. But without the right tools to disambiguate sales from demand in your analysis, brands are suffering from millions in lost revenue, bloated inventory, and missed opportunities.

The good news? It doesn't have to be this way. With the right approach and tools, you can make smarter inventory decisions that boost your bottom line. In this post, we'll dive deep into the critical differences between lost sales and stockouts and explore how cutting-edge machine learning tools can help you navigate these waters with precision and confidence.

Assess your inventory health with a free stockout assessment

Defining the Key Concepts

You’re likely very familiar with the differences between lost sales and stockouts, but to ensure we’re speaking the same language, here is a quick breakdown.

Lost Sales: The Hidden Cost

Lost sales occur when a customer is willing to buy a product, but for some reason, the sale doesn't happen. This could be due to various factors:

• The product is out of stock
• The product is in stock but not easily findable
• The customer service experience is poor
• The price is too high

Stockouts are just one potential cause of lost sales. The key characteristic of a lost sale is that it represents potential revenue that your business failed to capture.

Stockouts: The Visible Problem

A stockout, on the other hand, is a more specific issue. It occurs when a product is completely out of stock and unavailable for purchase. Stockouts can lead to lost sales, but not all lost sales are due to stockouts.

Stockouts are easier to track because they're visible in your inventory management system. However, they don't tell the whole story of lost sales.

The Danger of Conflation

When merchandising teams conflate lost sales and stockouts, frequently not due to lacking understanding but rather lacking tooling, they risk misdiagnosing inventory problems and implementing ineffective solutions. For example:

• Overcompensation Leading to Markdowns: When stockouts are mistaken for the full picture of lost sales, the knee-jerk reaction is often to overstock. This leads to excess inventory, increased carrying costs, and inevitable markdowns that eat into profits.
• Missed Opportunities in Other Areas: By focusing solely on preventing stockouts, you might overlook other significant sources of lost sales, such as pricing issues, poor merchandising, or inadequate marketing. This tunnel vision can leave substantial revenue on the table.
• Inaccurate Demand Forecasting: Conflating stockouts with all lost sales can skew your demand forecasts, leading to a cyclical problem of alternating shortages and surpluses.
• Customer Dissatisfaction and Lost Loyalty: While stockouts directly impact customer experience, other types of lost sales might be silently eroding your customer base without you even realizing it.
• Misallocation of Resources: Pouring all your resources into preventing stockouts when they're not the primary cause of lost sales is like applying a band-aid to a broken bone – it's an ineffective use of your time and budget.

Digging Deeper: Shadow Demand and Exposure

To truly optimize inventory management, we need to go beyond the surface-level understanding of lost sales and stockouts. Two critical concepts that can improve your approach are shadow demand and exposure.

Shadow Demand: Unveiling Hidden Opportunities

Shadow demand refers to the potential sales that aren't visible in your traditional sales data. It's the demand that exists but isn't fulfilled or sometimes even recognized. Here's why it matters:

1. Uncovering True Demand: Shadow demand helps you understand what your sales could have been under ideal conditions. This includes customers who wanted to buy but couldn't due to stockouts, as well as those who were interested but didn't purchase for other reasons.
2. Informing Product Development: By understanding shadow demand, you can identify unmet needs in your product line, potentially leading to new product ideas or variations.
3. Optimizing Marketing Strategies: Recognizing shadow demand can help you tailor your marketing efforts to capitalize on untapped interest.
4. Improving Forecasting: Incorporating shadow demand into your forecasting models can lead to more accurate predictions of future sales potential.

For example, if you notice high website traffic for a particular style that's frequently out of stock, that's an indicator of shadow demand. This information can guide restocking decisions and inform future production plans.

Exposure: Understanding the Ripple Effects

Exposure in inventory management refers to the full impact of a product's availability (or lack thereof) on overall demand, including its effects on complementary and substitute products. Here's why exposure is crucial:

1. Complementary Products: When one product is out of stock, it can negatively impact the sales of complementary items. For instance, if a popular sneaker is unavailable, you might see decreased sales in matching socks or shoe care products.
2. Substitute Products: Conversely, a stockout might drive sales of substitute products. If a particular running shoe is out of stock, customers might opt for a similar model.
3. Brand Perception: Consistent stockouts can affect overall brand perception, potentially impacting demand across your entire product line.
4. Customer Lifetime Value: Understanding exposure helps you gauge the long-term effects of inventory decisions on customer behavior and loyalty.

By factoring in exposure, you can make more holistic inventory decisions. For example, you might prioritize restocking a moderately popular item if it's known to drive sales of high-margin complementary products.

Using AI: A Two-Step Process for More Nuanced Inventory Management

AI algorithms can help separate the signal from the noise, providing insights that go beyond simple stockout data.

The Basics: How AI Can Help You Disentangle Lost Sales from Stockouts

AI-powered tools are particularly well-suited to help you separate demand from sales in your inventory performance. Here's how:

1. Demand Forecasting: AI models can analyze historical sales data, seasonal trends, and external factors to predict demand more accurately. This helps prevent both stockouts and overstock situations.
2. Lost Sales Estimation: By analyzing patterns in customer behavior, AI can estimate lost sales even when they're not directly observable. This provides a more complete picture of potential revenue.
3. Root Cause Analysis: AI algorithms can identify patterns and correlations that humans might miss, helping to pinpoint the true causes of lost sales beyond just stockouts.
4. Customer Behavior Prediction: By analyzing browsing and purchase patterns, AI can predict which customers are likely to make a purchase, allowing for targeted marketing and inventory allocation.

Advanced: Capture Shadow Demand and Understand Exposure with AI

With a baseline in place, you can turn your analysis to a more subtle exploration of shadow demand and exposure.

1. Pattern Recognition: AI algorithms can identify patterns in customer behavior that indicate shadow demand, such as abandoned carts, wishlist additions, or repeated searches for out-of-stock items.
2. Predictive Analytics: By analyzing historical data and current trends, AI can predict potential shadow demand for new or seasonal products.
3. Network Analysis: AI can map the relationships between products, helping you understand and quantify exposure across your product line.
4. Dynamic Pricing: AI-powered pricing tools can adjust prices based on shadow demand and exposure, maximizing revenue across your entire product ecosystem.
5. Personalized Recommendations: AI can use insights from shadow demand and exposure to improve product recommendations, potentially capturing sales that might otherwise be lost.

It’s important to remember that nuanced analysis of this sort is nearly impossible to accomplish without machine support. Lean on technology to deliver the insights your team needs, then challenge them to identify the clever strategies that will improve your performance.

Embracing AI for Smarter Inventory Management

With AI merchandising tools, you can gain a more nuanced understanding of your inventory challenges. These advanced analytics can help you distinguish different causes of lost sales, optimize your stock levels, and make data-driven decisions that boost your bottom line.

Learn more about how we apply advanced data science to our AI-powered merchandising software.